By Lehlohonolo Lehana.
The Labour Court handed down major rulings against the national leadership of the National Union of Metalworkers of South Africa (Numsa), led by General Secretary Irvin Jim and President Andrew Chirwa.
Numsa is currently facing an uphill battle to regain worker confidence amid leadership turmoil.
The union’s Central Committee had stripped Jim and Chirwa and other national office bearers of their powers ahead of the union’s 30 November congress, accusing them of neglecting their duties by cancelling meetings and failing to attend others.
The case was brought by seven Numsa regional leaders, who approached the court seeking to compel the national leadership to comply with its constitution.
They argued that the failure to convene ordinary National Executive Committee (NEC) meetings had left the union’s financial position without proper scrutiny for an extended period.
The court found that leaders violated Numsa’s constitution by missing quarterly NEC meetings since February 2025.
It ordered Jim to fund pending regional congresses and prohibited interference with the 2026 national elective conference.
Four regions, including KwaZulu-Natal, Sedibeng, Hlanganani, and Ekurhuleni, have not had regional congresses despite the expiry of their regional office bearers’ terms.
This means their current representatives do not have fresh mandates from their constituencies.
The regional congresses were expected to be held ahead of the scheduled national congress from November 30 to December 4, 2026.
Judge Edwin Tlhotlhalemaje denied the national leadership’s bid to appeal a ruling that stopped them from sidelining delegates or blocking a central committee meeting where their powers were curtailed.
A separate appeal regarding the Mpumalanga dispute was struck off the roll over a missing attorney mandate.
The Court accepted that the NUMSA Central Committee on 23 October 2026, acting pursuant to the Court’s earlier order, had resolved that:
- The litigation authority previously relied upon did not extend to the present dispute.
- Litigation in the name of NUMSA required proper constitutional authorisation.
- The union would abide by the Labour Court’s judgment of 22 October 2026.
- Attorneys purporting to act for NUMSA had no mandate to continue prosecuting the appeal in the union’s name.
The union media spokesperson Nkosinathi Makhanya said, “The Court has sent a clear message: individuals cannot hide behind the name of NUMSA while acting without NUMSA’s authority. The union’s name, resources and legal personality cannot be appropriated to pursue factional or personal agendas.”
“The significance of the judgment lies precisely in the fact that the Court did not entertain the fiction that authorisation could simply be presumed. Once authority was challenged, it had to be proved. When proof was not forthcoming, the litigation collapsed.”
